By Krishna Patel, Owner & Licensed General Contractor (CSLB #1132405) · Updated
The short answer
A garage conversion reuses a structure you already have, and state law says the city cannot make you replace the parking you lose. A new detached ADU gives you a layout and size of your choosing, within the city's limits, and keeps the garage. Which is better depends on the condition of the garage, how much space you need, your lot, and your budget, so price both before you decide.
What state law says about each
- Converting a garage: the city may not require you to replace the off-street parking when a garage, carport or covered parking structure is converted to an ADU.
- Converting existing space is not subject to the city's ADU size limits, and an ADU created from an existing accessory structure can add up to 150 square feet for ingress and egress.
- Building new and detached: a city may set a maximum size, but it must allow at least 850 square feet, or 1,000 square feet for an ADU with more than one bedroom. Where a city has no compliant ordinance, the state default maximum for a new detached ADU is 1,200 square feet.
- Either way, an ADU of 750 square feet of interior livable space or less is exempt from impact fees charged by local agencies, special districts and water corporations.
Garage conversion: the trade-offs
- You start with walls, a roof and a slab, but the garage was not built as living space. Insulation, windows, the slab, and plumbing and electrical runs all need to meet code for a dwelling.
- You lose the garage for parking and storage.
- The footprint is fixed by the existing structure, plus the 150 square feet state law allows for ingress and egress.
Detached ADU: the trade-offs
- You choose the size and layout within your city's limits, and you keep the garage.
- It needs a new foundation, framing, roof and utility connections, and usually more site work.
- Several cities offer pre-approved detached plans, which can shorten design and review. Anaheim's ADU Express, for example, only covers its pre-approved detached plans.
What each usually costs
In our experience, a garage conversion typically costs about 30% less than a new detached ADU, because the walls, roof and slab are already there.
ADUs in Orange County often run $150K to $400K or more overall (see our cost guide). Your real number depends on the structure, the lot, utilities and finishes. You get a written scope and price before any work starts.
Questions that decide it for your lot
- Is the garage in good enough shape to become living space?
- Do you need the garage for parking or storage?
- How much space does the ADU need to be, and for whom?
- Does your lot have room, access and utility capacity for a new structure?
- Does your city have a pre-approved detached plan that fits your lot?
- Is your home in an HOA, and what will its review ask for?
Related on this site
Sources
- California HCD: Accessory Dwelling Unit Handbook (March 2026)
- City of Anaheim: ADU Anaheim
- City of Santa Ana: ADU FAQs and Helpful Links
Last checked: . Rules and programs change, so confirm current requirements with the agency before you rely on them.
About Patel Precision Construction
We are a licensed Orange County general contractor (CSLB #1132405). We rebuild homes after water damage once a mitigation company has dried them out, working with your insurance adjuster, including Xactimate estimates and supplements. We also build ADUs and remodel kitchens and bathrooms. We do not do water extraction or drying.
ADU Construction in Orange County →